Cancel Culture Isn’t New - It’s Collective Accountability
Alt text: Stained-glass style abstract design with a central teal circle and X, surrounded by orange, green, and yellow geometric shapes.
“Cancel culture” isn’t about cancellation. It’s about accountability, powered by the speed, scale, and visibility of social media. What many call an overreaction is often a global audience drawing a line in the sand: enough. We’ve had enough of power without responsibility, enough of small moments that reflect big patterns, and enough of brands that preach values but practice silence.
It’s not a witch hunt. It’s a cultural shift.
Social Media: The World's Fastest Accountability Channel
We live in an age where every smartphone is a broadcast tower. A second of bad behavior doesn’t just travel; it goes global. Within hours, it’s been viewed, reposted, commented on, and debated by millions. But here's the truth: the outrage isn't about the moment. It’s about what the moment represents.
When a CEO is caught on camera in a compromising position (see: the Coldplay concert video), or an adult steals a baseball from a child (see: Phillies home run), or a grown man snatches a signed hat from a young tennis fan, what we’re really seeing is a crack in the social contract. These aren’t just personal lapses—they’re public reflections of deeper issues: entitlement, inequality, narcissism, and disregard for others.
These aren’t “oops” moments. They’re mirrors.
If It’s Caught on Camera, It’s Probably Not the First Time
Let’s stop pretending that what gets captured is the anomaly. More often than not, it’s the evidence. When a leader is filmed acting inappropriately, it’s rarely their first act of poor judgment—it’s just the first one with a digital witness. And if that’s how they act in public, what does that tell us about the culture they’ve cultivated behind closed doors?
The firing of CEOs following viral clips is often presented as swift justice. But if we look closer, many of these firings feel more like crisis containment than genuine change. One minute they’re out, the next they’re appointed to the board. Performative accountability, strategically timed to stabilize share prices—not driven by values, but by optics.
Ask yourself: if the board acted quickly only after the world saw the footage, what does that tell you about what they tolerated before?
The “One Bad Apple” Excuse Is Rotten
We’ve been told again and again that bad behavior is the exception. That one executive’s misstep doesn’t reflect the whole organization. But it does. Leadership character reflects company culture. A CEO is not an outlier. They are a product of the environment, often protected by it.
Let’s revisit the toxic workplace allegations at The Ellen DeGeneres Show. The program championed kindness on-air while fostering a damaging behind-the-scenes culture. It wasn’t just one person. It was a system that allowed harm to grow unchecked—until viewers and former staff made it impossible to ignore.
No values statement, annual report, or brand refresh can wallpaper over a rotten foundation. Eventually, the truth peels through.
This Isn’t Cancel Culture. It’s a Culture of Consequence.
What people want—what they’re voting for with their attention, their voices, and their wallets—is simple:
Fairness.
Equity.
Respect.
Decency.
It shouldn’t be radical to expect that people with power act responsibly. That leaders model values. That brands practice what they preach. What was once whispered in the margins is now public discourse. Epstein’s unsealed files, for example, spotlight not just individual crimes but the powerful institutions that looked the other way, protected names, and delayed justice. This is not just about personal wrongdoing—it’s about systemic rot.
“Cancel culture” is the modern mechanism by which regular people demand a higher standard—and get it.
The New Math of Brand Value: Character + Culture = Longevity
Brands can’t afford to ignore the moral calculus of modern consumers. In a fractured, uncertain world, people are choosing brands that reflect their values. It’s not just about quality or price—it’s about alignment.
And here’s the thing: consumers don’t just walk away silently. They walk away loudly—with hashtags, reels, think pieces, and screenshots.
Leadership must understand:
Advertising campaigns can’t save a broken culture.
Your internal practices will leak into your external reputation.
Values aren’t statements. They’re behaviours.
Today, being “cancelled” doesn’t mean someone wants your brand to disappear. It means they want you to do better—and they’re no longer giving you the benefit of the doubt while you figure it out.
What’s Next for Brands, Leaders, and Marketers?
If you’re leading an organization today, know this: we are living in the age of values verification. People are watching, not to catch you out—but to see if they can trust you. And trust is no longer built through perfect messaging. It’s built through consistent action.
Five questions every leader should be asking:
Do our internal policies reflect the values we put on our website?
Would our employees say the same thing about our culture that we say publicly?
Have we been silent when we should have been accountable?
Do we respond differently to issues based on who gets harmed?
Is our leadership a reflection of our ideals—or just our profits?
Cancel Culture Isn’t the Problem. It’s the Reckoning We Asked For.
We’re not more sensitive. We’re more aware. We’re not less forgiving. We’re less willing to accept silence, spin, and secrecy as leadership. The world hasn’t lost its mind—it’s finally finding its voice.
And that voice is saying: Character matters. Culture matters. People matter.
If your brand is built to last, build it on values you’re proud to have filmed.
Would you like this adapted into a LinkedIn carousel, blog, or a downloadable thought leadership piece with visuals and a call-to-action? I can also create a checklist or boardroom workshop companion based on this article.
